diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'meeting-minutes/minutes-2022-03-22.txt')
-rw-r--r-- | meeting-minutes/minutes-2022-03-22.txt | 152 |
1 files changed, 152 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/meeting-minutes/minutes-2022-03-22.txt b/meeting-minutes/minutes-2022-03-22.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..94893af --- /dev/null +++ b/meeting-minutes/minutes-2022-03-22.txt @@ -0,0 +1,152 @@ +Meeting Date: 2022-03-22 +Minutes taken by: Matt +Attendees: + Dmitry Belyavsky + Matthias St. Pierre + Shane Lontis + Matt Caswell + Nicola Tuveri + Richard Levitte + Tomas Mraz + Tim Hudson + Paul Dale + Hugo Landau + +Agenda: + + * Nominate a minute taker and confirm agenda + * Agree minutes from previous meeting + * Review outstanding actions + * Review the QUIC API proposal + * Discuss release requirements policy (technical-policies #27) + * Performance + * Review issues with OTC hold (30 minutes) + * Review draft technical policies + * Allocation of tasks to staff + * Agree agenda for next meeting + * AOB + +** Nominate a minute taker and confirm agenda + +Matt volunteered to take the minutes. +Proposed: Matt, seconded: Tim + +Agenda for the meeting agreed. Proposed: Matt, seconded: Tim, Tomas + +** Agree minutes from previous meeting + +Last week minutes were approved. +Proposed: Tomas, seconded: Matt + +** Review outstanding actions + +AI: Hugo to repeat the tests in 15199 and get new performance figures. +Done + +AI: Matt to do adjustments on the QUIC technical requirements document: + + - to add 6 month releases, and internal CI for primary platforms as objectives + to the document. Also explicitly mention that in MVP for the next release the + pluggable record layer interface will be internal. + - to mention the internal plumbing should allow for the fact that we may want + to be able to support single copy APIs in future. In addition to the existing + interface. And put the existing "single copy" bullets under it. + The performance comparability should be aimed at a future release. + - to add 'Support' to the last bullet of MVP requirements. + Done + +AI: Matt to update the document and start a vote after two days unless there +is a major discussion ongoing on the PR. +In Progress + + +** Review the QUIC API proposal + +The current proposal does not cover what the API will look like in 3.1 for the +MVP. + +Discussion around how we would handle timer based events in the "simple one line +change" to an application for MVP. Possibly with a thread. We will have both +the ability to run timer events via a thread AND the ability to run via idle +callback. + +We need some way of hiding the differences between the TCP socket and UDP socket +creation. + +How will we do blocking? + +How do we work without a visible event capability for existing applications? + +Discussion about being able to configure which protocol we want via a string. + +AI: Update the QUIC API proposal with approach to solving the 5 problems +(1) timer based events (2) TCP vs UDP socket creation (3) blocking (4) no visible +event capability for existing apps (5) configure protocol via a string. + +AI: Separate out in the API proposal the subset we will implement for MVP. + +AI: Matt to extend out the description of SSL_new_stream() to make it clearer that +in the TLS context it creates a new connection. + +Discussion about the need for good demos and documentation for QUIC. + +** Discuss release requirements policy (technical-policies #22) + +Requirement is to take the existing text (see technical-policies #22 and main +repo #15326) +AI: Tomas to write a draft release requirements policy in the next sprint + +** Performance + +Tim provided some links on peformance: + +https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-banks-quic-performance +https://microsoft.github.io/msquic/index.html#hardware + + +** Review issues with OTC hold (30 minutes) + +#17931 (lh stats) Discussion about whether this is ok for master. Proposal that +we could remove the hash counting code completely. +OTC decision is to always report 0 for the stats in both master and 3.0. In +addition we should deprecate the functions in master. + +** Review draft technical policies + +Deferred + +** Allocation of tasks to staff + +No change. + +** Agree agenda for next meeting + + * Nominate a minute taker and confirm agenda + * Agree minutes from previous meeting + * Review outstanding actions + * Review the QUIC API + * Review issues with OTC hold (30 minutes) + * Review draft technical policies + * Allocation of tasks to staff + * Agree agenda for next meeting + * AOB + +** AOB + +None + +** New and carried over action items [transported from above]: + +AI: Matt to update the technical requirements document and start a vote after +two days unless there is a major discussion ongoing on the PR. + +AI: Update the QUIC API proposal with approach to solving the 5 problems +(1) timer based events (2) TCP vs UDP socket creation (3) blocking (4) no visible +event capability for existing apps (5) configure protocol via a string. + +AI: Separate out in the API proposal the subset we will implement for MVP. + +AI: Matt to extend out the description of SSL_new_stream() to make it clearer that +in the TLS context it creates a new connection. + +AI: Tomas to write a draft release requirements policy in the next sprint |